Military Necessity - LCC vs. USLS

I Debate

25th Episode

November 15, 2006

I-Debate Challenge 2006

1st Bacolod Inter-School Debate Tournament

High School Level

3rd Semi-Final Match

La Consolacion College (LCC)

- versus -

University of St. La Salle (USLS)

Winning Team: USLS

3-2 Split Decision

Topic:

"Can the Death of Civilians Ever be Justified by Military Necessity?"

Affirmative: LCC

Wassily Clavecillas

Frances Mae Baquillos

Coach:

Mr. Wilfredo Porquido, Sr.

Negative: USLS

JoVanne Tamparon

Yones Irene de Castro

Coach:

Ms. Lelanie Reforma

JUDGES:

Ms. Emily Go-Villanueva

Proprietor - IEC Computers

UP Graduate

Atty. Lilanie Griño-Lorque

Graduate of Silliman University College of Law

Partner - Griño Law Offices

Atty. Pauline Tumonong

Graduate, UNO-R College of Law

Atty. Mary Ann Lamis

Assistant Provincial Legal Officer

Province of Negros Occidental

Ms. Suzette Santander

English Teacher

Holy Family High School

Decision:

3-2 Split Decision in favor of the Negative Side (USLS)